John Ortberg Resigns from Menlo Church. Church says there’s no evidence of misconduct
John Ortberg, renowned Christian author and speaker, has resigned as pastor of Menlo Church, a megachurch congregation outside of San Francisco. His resignation becomes effective Sunday, August 2.
“I have considered my 17 years as pastor here to be the greatest joy I’ve had in ministry,” Ortberg remarked in a statement. “But this has been a difficult time for parents, volunteers, staff, and others, and I believe that the unity needed for Menlo to flourish will be best served by my leaving.”
In November, Ortberg was placed on leave after it came to the knowledge of Menlo Church elders that he allowed a volunteer who had revealed about being attracted to children to work with kids at the church and in the community.
Ortberg had initially learned of the volunteer’s admission in July 2018. He did not let other church leaders or the youth sports team know that the volunteer coached. Church leaders had no knowledge of his actions until Daniel Lavery, Ortberg’s son, sent an email blowing the whistle.
The elder Ortberg returned to the pulpit this spring after the elders employed a lawyer to conduct an inquiry into the matter.
However, controversy at the church broke out again after Lavery disclosed that the volunteer in question was his younger brother and the pastor’s youngest son. This is a fact that had been withheld from the congregation.
Lavery, former friends of the Ortberg family, and other critics of the decision have requested that the pastor step down.
Issue of misconduct
Questions were also raised about the inquiry into possible misconduct, as the lawyer the church hired did not talk to parents or to any children or youth who the volunteer had worked with.
No allegations of misconduct on the part of Ortberg’s youngest son have been made.
Betrayal of trust
Earlier this month, a spokesman for the church’s elders informed Religion News Service that their pastor had betrayed the trust of church members and leaders. Rebuilding that trust would be intricate if Ortberg remained as pastor, the elders said in the July 29 statement declaring his resignation.
They also said the church is presently organizing a new, more extensive investigation.
“Our decision stems from a collective desire for healing and discernment focused on three primary areas,” the elders remarked in a statement.
“First, John’s poor judgment has resulted in pain and broken trust among many parents, youth, volunteers, and staff. Second, the extended time period required to complete the new investigation and rebuild trust will significantly delay our ability to pursue Menlo’s mission with the unity of spirit and purpose we believe God calls us to. Third, in this coming season John needs to focus on healing and reconciliation within his own family.”
On Ortberg’s ultimate days as pastor, he will address the congregation during an online service this weekend. He has served as Menlo’s pastor for 17 years. Prior to that, he was a teaching pastor at Willow Creek Community Church near Chicago.
In his statement, Ortberg recounts that he regretted “not having served our church with better judgment.”
“Extensive conversations I had with my youngest son gave no evidence of risk of harm, and feedback from others about his impact was consistently positive,” he said. “However, for my part, I did not balance my responsibilities as a father with my responsibilities as a leader.”
John Ortberg, 63, presented his resignation to the church’s elders this week. The decision to end his call as pastor has to be approved at the church’s annual meeting, now scheduled for August 30.
A transitional pastor expected
In consultation with denominational officials, church elders intend to bring on a transitional pastor. They also plan to add new elder at the forthcoming congregational meeting.
“The Elder Board acknowledges that it is ultimately accountable for creating an environment of trust and mutual respect which has been sorely tested these last few months,” according to the statement. “We feel called to provide stability to Menlo Church in this time of significant transition but are working to add new and diverse voices on the board.”